?br />
? ?
?? ?? ???
??
DISPELLING VACCINATION MYTHS
An introduction to the contradictions between medical science and immunization policy
?by Alan Phillips (
[email protected]). Last Revision: February 1997.
Informed Parents Vaccination WWW, URL:
https://www.unc.edu/~aphillip/www/vaccine/imformed.htm
? ? ? ? ? , ? ? ? ?????, ? ??
: Vaccine Awareness, P.O. Box 62282, Durham, NC 27715
????(. ).
? ?
????? ? ? 2 ?? ? , ? , ?. ?: ??????DPT (Diptheria-pertussis-tetanus - ?--? 1 ?1750, ? ? ??? ?- 1 ?? ? ?? , , ? ? ? ? ? , ? ? ?..? ?? ??? ??? - ? ? ? ?? ?????, ? ?? ? ? ?
? ? ?? ?? ? ?, ??? ?FDA (Food and Drug Administration - ? ? ?, ?CDC (Centers for Disease Control - ? ) ??? ?.
?: ??? ? ; ?? ????? ? ???? ? ?? ?? ?, ? ? ? ??? ???
? ?, ? ? ?? ???, ?? , ? ? ? ? , ?????????. ?? ? ??, ?? ???? ? ? ? ?? ?? ? ?.
? ?? ? -, ? ? ?? ??? ?? ? ? ?? ???, ? ??? ??, ?? ? ? ? ? ? ?, ?????? ?? ?? ?? ? , ?????- ?
? ? ?, ? , ??? ?? ??? ? ? ?? , ??- ?? ??- ? ?.
: ? ?? ?? ? ? ?????? , ?? ????. ?? ?
?? N1:
??..?br />
... ? ?
?VAERS (FDA's Vaccine Adverse Effects Reporting System - ?? ? ?? ?11000 ?????, ?1% (?112 ? ?- ? ? ? [1] ? ??? ??? ?? ?? ?P?? DPT (Diptheria-pertussis-tetanus - ?--?.
?? , ? ? ? FDA ? ?? ?10% ?? [2] ?? ? NVIC (National Vaccine Information Center - ?). [3] , NVIC ?? ? ? ?? 40 ? [2%] , ? ? ? ?? ?. ?? ??97.5 % ??? ?? ??? ??? ( ?? ?? ?????. ??, ? ? ?1000 ? .
? ? ?? ????? ?? ? ?10 ( CDC), ? 8 ?1993 , ??? ( ? ?3-4 , ? ? ? ?. ?, ???100 ??, ? ?
? ?, ? ?? ?( ?N2), ?? , ??? ? ? ? ( ?? 79% ; ?N3), ?, ???. ???? ? ???? ? , ?
?? ?? ? . ? ??? , ?? ? SIDS [4, 5] ("Sudden Infant Death Syndrome?- ??? - ?? ??, ? ? ; ? - 5000 10000 ???).
, ?????SIDS ?? 2 4 ?? ?? , ? ? ??? [4]. ??- ? ?? , ? ???3000 ????4 ?. (? ? ? ? ?SIDS ?). ? ??, ? ?SIDS - 2500 5000 ???? ?- ?? [4]
?, ?? ? SIDS - ? ? ???, ?, ? ? . [6] , ?? ? ?????? ? ? ?? SIDS?
? 70-??? ? ?2 ?? 2 ? ????SIDS ?? ? ? ? ?? . ? ?SIDS ?? ? ?? ?, ? ?? ???
?? ????, ????? ? ? ? , ?100000. - ?, ? ? ?? ?- ? , , ????? ??( ?). ? ? ? ?? ?1 175 ? ? ? DPT, ? , [7] ??? ? ?? ?1 300 ?DPT ?? [8]
? ? ? ? ?? 70-??? ? ?80% 30%. ? ? (B. Trollfors) ???? ? ? , ?? ??? ? ?? ????????? ???. ?? ??, ??? ? ?? ??1970 , ????? ??? 80-?? ? ??. [9]
??? ?? ????? ? ?NVICP (National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program - ? ? ?? ? ? ) ? ?724.4 ??? ? ? .
?? ?5000 ?1988 , ?700 ? , ? ?? ?2000 ???? ??? . [10] ?? ?? ?? 50 ?(? ?? ? ??; ?N9), ? , ? ? ? ? ? ?, ? ? ??? ?, ?? ? . ? ; ?? ? ? ? , ? ? ?? ? ? ?
? ?? (? ? ) ? ?? . , ?????, ??.
? N1:
?????? ? ???
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
?? N2:
?...?br />
... ? ?
? , ??. ?, , , ? Hib - ???? . [11, 12, 13, 14 ,15] ?1989 CDC ? ??, ?[] ?? ?? 98%. [16] [] ? ?, , ? ? [17] CDC ??? ?, 100%. [18] , ?, ? ?? ? ?? , ? . [19] ?? ? ? , ?? ?? ?? ?. [19a]
?? , ? ? . ?? ?? ?? ? ??? ? , ? ?? ?1872 . 1892 ??29979 ???? ? [20] ?? , ? ???? ? ?8 ?? 24.5 ?? ? ? . [21] ?1989 ??? ?????? . [22] ???1986 , 90% ? ?? ?? [23] 72% ?? ?? ?1993 , ? ?. [24]
? N2:
, ?? - ? ? ?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
?? N3:
- ? ??? ??...?br />
... ? ?
? ?(British Association for the Advancement of Science), ?? 90% ?1850 ?1940 , ?? ??, ? .
??? ?????? , ?? 80% ( ??? 97%) [25] ?, ?1950 ?? 82% ? ? ?? ???1956 .
?? ? ?? ?? ? ? . ? ? ?, ??? ?, ? ? ?? ?, ?, ? ? ?, ?? ? , ??. (, ? ? ? ? ?? ??. ? ? ? . ? ? ? ??? ??? ?? [26])
? ? ? ??? ?? ? ?, ? ? - ? ? , ? ?? ??- ?? ? ?? ?? (World Health Organization), ?? ? ? ?? ??????? , ? ???. [27] ? ? , ?, ? .
? ? ?? ??? ? . ?? ? - ???? ?? ? ? ? ?? ??? ??? ??. [28] , ????, ? 3.2% ? ?? ????.
?1974 CDC ? ?? 36 ?, ? ? ???? ?660 ?? [29] ?1982 ? ? ? ???DPT - ?? ?DPT; , ? ????? ?(U.S. Division of Biological Standards) . (Dr. J. Anthony Morris) ?41 , 5 , ?? ? ? [30] ? , , ? ? ???
? N3:
? ????? ?????
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
?? N4:
? ??...?br />
... ? ?
?? - ? ???? ?, ? ?. ? ? , - ? ???? ? , ? - ? ?, ? ? ???, ?? . [31] ?, , ??(British Medical Council) ?1950 , ? ? ? ??? ? ??? ??????. [32] ? - ??, ?? ? ?? ? ?
?, ?? ? ?? ?? ? ?? . ?? ?? , ???. [33]
? ?- ? , ?, ?? ? ?? , ??. ???N2 , ??, ?- ???? .?? ?? ?? . [19] ???, ??Hib ? ? ? , ?? ? ? ?? ?, ??.
? ? - ? . ?? ?? ?? ? ?. , 100 ???5 ? , ??? ??95%. 10 100 ? ?? ? ? 50%. ??? ???- ??- ? ?? ? ?.
? ? ? ?? ??, ?? , ? 8 2 ? ? ?, ??40- ?. ?, ? ?? ?? ( ), ?? .
?, ? , ?? ?? 1/2 3 ? ??? , ????? ??- ???? ? NVIC, FDA ? , ?? ?. , ?? ?- ?? ? ????
??, , ??, , , ? ? ? ? ??? , ?? ? , ??? ???? ? ? ?? ?- 50% - ?. [34] ?? ?(A. Kalokerinos, M.D.) , ? ?? ?(?? ?? ? (? ?, ?? ? ? ? ? ? ? , ? ???. ?, ???. ??? ?, ?, , ? ?? ??
?? ? ???? (New England Journal of Medicine), ?, ? ??? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ????: ? ??? 8 ? 2 9 ?27 ? ?10 ?? ?182 . ( ? 22 1995 ).
?? ?? ? ? ???. ? ?? ? ? ? ! ?? ??? ?? ?, ?? ? , ????ee ?
? N4:
? ? , ? ? ? ? ?? ?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
?? N5:
??...?br />
... ? ?
?? ?? ???. ? CDC ???1992-94 ? ? 99.8 %. , ???? ?1993 ???? ? ? ? : ? ? ?? ?????.
???? ? ?. ??? ?? ??? . , ? ???? ??? , ?? ???6-10 ? ?, ? ? ? ?, ? ??20 ???
? ? ??1980-? ? ?, ? ? ? . [35] ???? ? 6 ?? [36] ?, ??? ??, ?? ?? ? ??????? ? ? . [37] ? ?(Dr. A. Lavin) ? . (Dept. of Pediatrics, St. Luke's Medical Center) ??( ? ?? ?, ? ? ... ? ??(?) ???[]? [38] ??? ? ?? ?? ?? .
? ?, ?? ? ?? ? , ? ? ?? , ? ??? ??, ? ?? ??
? N5:
? , ? ?, .
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
?? N6:
?? ? ...?br />
... ? ?
? ? ? ? ??? ??, ? ???(Salk), ? ?? ???? 642%. ?1959 77.5% ??? 3 IPV (injected polio vaccine - ???. ? ????1962 ? (Dr. Bernard Greenberg), ? ???? (Dept. of Biostatistics for the University of North Carolina School of Public Health), ?, ? ??? ( 50% ?1957 1958 ? 80% ?1958 1959 ?, ? ?? ? ? ??, ? ?? [39]
? ?(Dr. Viera Scheibner), 90% ? ? ? ? , ? ?? ?? ?? ?? ?? , ? , ???
(, ?? ?? ? ????? ?????? ? ?? ?? ? ?? , ??20 35; ?? ? ?? ? ?24 ? ??60 . ? ?? ? ?? - ? .)
?1985 CDC ? ?87% ? ???1973 ?1983 ?, ???? ?????? ?, ?? ???? ?
(Jonas Salk), IPV, ? , , ???? ?1961 ? ??. ? , ? ? ? , ??(Dr. Samuel Katz) (Duke University) ?8-10 ??? ?? ?? ? ? ??, ? , ?.
?(Jessica Scheer) ??? ? (National Rehabilitation Hospital Research Center), ? ??? ? ? ? ? ? . ??? ?? ??? NVIC c ? ?? ? ??, ? ? ? ??, ??? CDC.
? N6:
? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ?.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
?? N7:
?? ? ? , ?? ???...?br />
... ? ?
? ?? ? ??? ??, ? ?, ( ?), , ??, ? 30 ???? ? ?? ??, ? ?. ? ?(the Poisons Information Centre) ??, ???? ? ?? ? .
?, ??? ?(Harris Coulter, Ph.D. ) ?, ?? ? ? ?.. ??? ?? ? ??? ? , - ?15-20% . ? ?? [? ? ??]: , ??, ? , , ??, ?, ? ? , , ? ?- ? , ? ?. ??? ? ????? ?. ??? ????, ???? ?
??? ?22 , ?? ?? ??? ? ? ?? ? ? ? . ????? ; ??? ? , ??? ?? .
? N7:
??? , ? ?? ? ?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
?? N8:
- ? ? ? ...
... ? ?
???? ?? ? ? ? ?100% , . ???? ? ?? ???? . ? ?1849 ? ?? 48-60%, ? ?? ??? 3%. [40]
??. [41] ? , ?? ???????. , ??, ?? ? ?, ? ?? ?100% ? - ? ? . [42]
?? ? . [43] ???? ??(?, ???) ? ????? ????? ?? ??? . ?, ? ????? ? ? ? ?? ?? ??? ? ?
? N8:
??? ? ?? , ? ???
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
?? N9:
? ?? ? ...?br />
... ? ?
?? ??? :
1) ?: ?50 ? ?. ? ? ? ??. ????, ???? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ?? - ?? ???? ?? ?? ??? ?.
2) ?: ??? ?. ??? ?? ? ?? ?? ??;
3) ?? : ? , ? ??????, ? ?.
???? ? ??, ????? ??? ????? ? ? ?.
?? ?? - ? ?? . ? ????? , ????? .
? N9:
?? ? ?( ? ?.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
?? N10:
?? ? ?..?br />
... ? ?
? ?, ? ???? ?, ? ??? ? ? . (The United Kingdom's Department of Health) , ? ??: ? ??? ? ? ??? ? ???? ????? ??? ?
???? ?. ?-, ?? ?? ? ( ?, ? ). , - ?? ??, ?? ?? ? ? ? ? ??? ?? ? ????? ? ??, ? ?? , , ??, ?? ?? ?. , ?? ?? ? ??. ?? ? ? ?? ? ?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
?? ?(December, 1994 Medical Post) ???? ?("Medical Mafia") ?(Guylaine Lanctot, M.D.) ? ? ? ? ?? ? ?? ?. ? ? ?? ... ?10 ? , ? ? . ? ? ? , ?? ? ? ?? ? ?, , ?? ? .
? ?(John B. Classen, M.D., M.B.A.) ? , ??, ?? ?? , ? ? ? - ? ?? ? ? ??, ?? ? ?? ?? ?? ? ? ? ? ?(The American Society of Microbiology) ?... ?? ??? ? ? ?? - ? ?? ? ?, , ? ???. ???????, ? ?? ? . ? ? ? ? ? ? ???? ???
? ??. NVIC, ??250 ? ? ? ? ??(), ?100 ??? ??? ? ?? ? ??? (, !), ? ?, ??? . ?(?) ?- ? ? ?? ? ??- ?. ?? ? ? ? . ?, ???? ? ? . ? ? ? ? ? , ? ?.
?? ? ?, ?? ???? ??? ???, ?, ?????.
? ? ? ???:
?!
? ?Dispelling Vaccination Myths??? ? (? ? , ? ? ?? ? , ?? ?WWW ???) ?7 ? ? Vaccine Awareness, P.O. Box 62282, Durham, NC 27715-2282,
?? ? ??
https://www.unc.edu/~aphillip/www/vaccine/informed.htm
?? ??
[email protected]
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
...
?? ? ??? ? ? ? ? ?1996 ? ("Wildfire Magazine"), ??? ? ??? ?. ? (Sheffield School of Homeopathy, UK.). ? ??? (Australian Minister for Human Services and Health), ?(Immunization Investigation Group) ? ?? (the Campaign Against Fraudulent Medical Research) ???, .
?? ?? ?????(Human Development Services, Inc.), ? ?? ?. - ? ?? ?? , ???? ?? ?? ??? ? ? ?? ??? B.A. Magna Cum Laude, ? ?? ?(Phi Kappa Phi National Honor Society) ? (The National Dean's List).
? (?):
(1) National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA 22161, 703-487-4650, 703-487-4600.
(2) Reported by KM Severyn, R.Ph.,Ph.D. in the Dayton Daily News, May 28, 1993. (Ohio Parents for Vaccine Safety, 251 Ridgeway Dr., Dayton, OH 45459)
(3) National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC), 512 Maple Ave. W. #206, Vienna, VA 22180, 703-938-0342; "Investigative Report on the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System."
(4) Viera Scheibner, Ph.D., Vaccination: 100 Years of Orthodox Research Shows that Vaccines Represent a Medical Assault on the Immune System.
(5) W.C. Torch, "Diptheria-pertussis-tetanus (DPT) immunization: A potential cause of the sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS)," (Amer. Adacemy of Neurology, 34th Annual Meeting, Apr 25 - May 1, 1982), Neurology 32(4), pt. 2.
(6) Confounding in studies of adverse reactions to vaccines [see comments]. Fine PE, Chen RT, REVIEW ARTICLE: 38 REFS. Comment in: Am J Epidemiol 1994 Jan 15;139(2):229-30. Division of Immunization, Centers for Disease Control, Atlanta, GA 30333.
(7) Nature and Rates of Adverse Reactions Associated with DTP and DT Immunizations in Infants and Children" (Pediatrics, Nov. 1981, Vol. 68, No. 5)
(8) The Fresno Bee, Community Relations, 1626 E. Street, Fresno, CA 93786, DPT Report, December 5, 1984.
(9) Trollfors B, Rabo, E. 1981. Whooping cough in adults. British Medical Journal (September 12), 696-97.
(10) National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (NVICP), Health Resources and Services Administration, Parklawn Building, Room 7-90, 5600 Fishers Lane, Rockville, MD 20857, 800-338-2382.
(11) Measles vaccine failures: lack of sustained measles specific immunoglobulin G responses in revaccinated adolescents and young adults. Department of Pediatrics, Georgetown University Medical Center, Washington, DC 20007. Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal. 13(1):34-8, 1994 Jan.
(12) Measles outbreak in 31 schools: risk factors for vaccine failure and evaluation of a selective revaccination strategy. Department of Preventive Medicine and Biostatistics, University of Toronto, Ont. Canadian Medical Association Journal. 150(7):1093-8, 1994 Apr 1.
(13) Haemophilus b disease after vaccination with Haemophilus b polysaccharide or conjugate vaccine. Institution Division of Bacterial Products, Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research, Food and Drug Administration, Bethesda, Md 20892. American Journal of Diseases of Children. 145(12):1379-82, 1991 Dec.
(14) Sustained transmission of mumps in a highly vaccinated population: assessment of primary vaccine failure and waning vaccine-induced immunity. Division of Field Epidemiology, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia. Journal of Infectious Diseases. 169(1):77-82, 1994 Jan. 1.
(15) Secondary measles vaccine failure in healthcare workers exposed to infected patients. Department of Pediatrics, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, PA 19104. Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology. 14(2):81-6, 1993 Feb.
(16) MMWR, 38 (8-9), 12/29/89).
(17) MMWR (Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report) "Measles." 989; 38:329-330.
(18) Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR). 33(24), 6/22/84.
(19) Failure to reach the goal of measles elimination. Apparent paradox of measles infections in immunized persons. Review article: 50 REFS. Dept. of Internal Medicine, Mayo Vaccine Research Group, Mayo Clinic and Foundation, Rochester, MN. Archives of Internal Medicine. 154(16):1815-20, 1994 Aug 22.
(19a) Clinical Immunology and Immunopathology, May 1996; 79(2): 163-170.
(20) Trevor Gunn, Mass Immunization, A Point in Question, p 15 (E.D. Hume, Pasteur Exposed-The False
Foundations of Modern Medicine, Bookreal, Australia, 1989.)
(21) Physician William Howard Hay's address of June 25, 1937; printed in the Congressional Record.
(22) Outbreak of paralytic poliomyelitis in Oman; evidence for widespread transmission among fully vaccinated children Lancet vol 338: Sept 21, 1991; 715-720.
(23) Neil Miller, Vaccines: Are They Safe and Effective? p 33.
(24) Chicago Dept. of Health.
(25) See Note 23 pp 18-40.
(26) See Note 23 pp 45,46 [NVIC News, April 92, p12].
(27) S. Curtis, A Handbook of Homeopathic Alternatives to Immunization.
(28) Darrell Huff, How to Lie With Statistics, p 84.
(29) quoted from the internet, credited to Keith Block, M.D., a family physician from Evanston, Illinois, who has spent years collecting data in the medical literature on immunizations.
(30) See Note 20, p 15.
(31) See Note 20 p 21.
(32) See Note 20, p 21 (British Medical Council Publication 272, May 1950)
(33) See Note 20, p 21; also Note 23 p 47 (Buttram, MD, Hoffman, Mothering Magazine, Winter 1985 p 30;
Kalokerinos and Dettman, MDs, "The Dangers of Immunization," Biological Research Inst. [Australia], 1979, p 49).
(34) Archie Kalolerinos, MD, Every Second Child, Keats Publishing, Inc. 1981
(35) Reported by KM Severyn,R.Ph,Ph.D. in the Dayton Daily News, June 3, 1995.
(36) Vaccine Information and Awareness, "Measles and Antibody Titre Levels," from Vaccine Weekly, January 1996.
(37) NVIC Press Release, "Consumer Group Warns use of New Chicken Pox Vaccine in all Healthy Children May Cause More Serious Disease".
(38) See note 35 (quoted from The Lancet)
(39) Hearings before the Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce, House of Representatives, 87th Congress, Second Session on H.R. 10541, May 1962, p.94.
(40) Ullman, Discovering Homeopathy, p 42 (Thomas L. Bradford, Logic Figures, p68, 113-146; Coulter, Divided Legacy, Vol 3, p268).
(41) See Note 27.
(42) See Note 27.
(43) Golden, Isaac, Vaccination? A Review of Risks and Alternatives.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A. ??
1)Sumeria Virtual Library, ? 1996 ??:
https://www.livelinks.com/sumeria/health/myth2.html
2) Informed Parents Vaccination Home Page, ? 1996 ??:
https://www.unc.edu/~aphillip/www/vaccine/informed.htm
3) Dispelling Vaccination Myths Mirror Site, ? 1997 ??:
https://www.ideasign.com/chiliast/vaccine/dvm1.htm
B. ?
1) Health Action Network, U.K. ()
2) The National Vaccine Information Center, Vienna, VA
3) The Parent's Information Network, WV
4) The Vaccine Awareness Network, Australia
5) Vaccine Information and Awareness (VIA), CA
6) Sai Sanjeevini Foundation, India ()
7) Hindustan Times, N. India, ?1997 (?1 ?
C. ? ????
1) Sheffield School of Homeopathy, UK, I. Townsend, Instr., 1996
2) UNC-Chapel Hill, School of Medicine, S. G., Ph.D., Instr., ?1997